Times Square Subway Station

The Reduction Effect

Last week I talked about how high-frequency words and phrases resist analogical change. This entrenchment happens because analogical change is driven by forgetting, and it’s harder to forget something that you’ve said a lot. In this post I want to talk about a different effect of frequency, the reduction effect, where high-frequency words and phrases get shortened and simplified.

We see reduction in all the words and phrases we say most often. “How are you?” becomes “Hiya” and then “Hi.” “I don’t know” becomes “I dunno” and then something I can’t even write, a single “uh” vowel with a low-high-low tone pattern. “I am going to let you” becomes “I’m gonna let you,” and then, in the speech of Kanye West and Eminem, “amaletchoo.”

A lot of people find these frequency effects confusing. How can high frequency words and phrases be simultaneously the first to change and the last to change? What makes this possible is that they are two different kinds of change. Entrenchment is about forgetting, and the more we do things, the more we remember how to do them. Reduction is about ease, and the more we do things the easier they become.

This is like any habit. Because I take the subway to Times Square so frequently, I not only never forget the way, but I do all kinds of things to make it faster and easier. I know where to stand on the platform, where to sit on the train, and when to stand up, so that I get off right by the most convenient staircase.

More importantly, I have a low-level “muscle memory” of the movements involved in the trip. Every time, I climb the stairs the same way, sit down the same way, stand up the same way. It’s the same with unlocking my apartment door or cooking a steak. My movements are all smaller and smoother. I can do a lot of it without thinking.

As with entrenchment, I learned about the Reduction Effect in class with Joan Bybee. In one of her early papers, published in 1976 under the name Joan B. Hooper, she credits Hugo Schuchardt with discovering the relationship. In 1885 (German PDF p. 28 | English translation p. 56), Schuchardt wrote, “What is more natural than making things easier whenever frequency provides the strongest impulse for this and wherever the danger of misunderstanding is least?”

I know I said I’d talk about why it’s not so surprising that we get “snuck.” I’m almost there; I wanted to get this relatively straightforward stuff out of the way first.

One way of generating spam

This showed up today in the comments that Akismet flagged for spam:

{Photo|Picture|Photograph|Image|Photography|Snapshot|Shot|Pic|Photographic|Graphic|Pics} {credit|credit score|credit rating|credit history|credit ratings|consumer credit|credit ranking|credit standing|consumer credit rating|credit scores|credit worthiness}: {AP|Elp} | {FILE|Document|Record|Report|Data file|Submit|Computer file|Data|Register|Archive|Database} #file_links\keywords1.txt,1,S] {-|–|:|*|( space )|( blank )|,|To|. . .|And|As} {In this|Within this|On this|With this|In this particular|During this|In such a|Through this|From this|In that|This particular} {O|To|A|E|I|U|} #file #file_links\keywords2.txt,1,S] _links\keywords3.txt,1,S] ct. {7|Seven|Several|6|8|Six|5|Five|9|Eight|10}, {2012|Next year}, {file|document|record|report|data file|submit|computer file|data|register|archive|database} {photo|picture|photograph|image|photography|snapshot|shot|pic|photographic|graphic|pics}, {Chicago|Chi town|Chicago, il|Detroit|Dallas|Chicago, illinois|Philadelphia|Los angeles|Denver|Chicagoland|Miami} {Bears|Has|Contains|Holds|Carries|Provides|Offers|Includes|Teddy bears|Requires|Features} {middle|center|midsection|midst|heart|centre|core|mid|central|middle section|middle of the} linebacker {Brian|John|Mark} Urlacher {watches|wrist watches|timepieces|designer watches|wristwatches|different watches|pieces|running watches|looks after|monitors|devices} {from the|in the|from your|through the|on the|with the|within the|belonging to the|out of the|out of your|of your} {sideline|part time} {during the|throughout the|through the|in the|over the|while in the|within the|all through the|through|usually in the|within} {second half|other half|better half|lover|wife or husband|partner|loved one} {of an|of the|of your|associated with an|connected with an|of|of any|of each|associated with the|of some|associated with} {NFL|National football league|American footbal|Football|Nhl|Nba} {football|soccer|sports|basketball|baseball|hockey|footballing|rugby|nfl|golf|nfl football} {game|sport|video game|online game|recreation|activity|match|adventure|gameplay|performance|gaming} {against the|from the|up against the|contrary to the|resistant to the|about the|with the|on the|versus the|with|around the} {Jacksonville Jaguars|Gambling} {in|within|inside|throughout|with|around|during|on|when it comes to|for|found in} {Jacksonville|The city of jacksonville|The town of jacksonville}, Fla. {The|The actual|The particular|Your|This|A|Any|Typically the|All the|That|All of the} {Bears|Has|Contains|Holds|Carries|Provides|Offers|Includes|Teddy bears|Requires|Features} {announced|introduced|declared|released|reported|proclaimed|publicised|publicized|launched|revealed|stated} {on|upon|about|in|with|for|regarding|concerning|at|relating to|on the subject of} {Wednesday|Thursday|Friday|Wed|Saturday|Sunday|Mondy|Monday|The following friday|The following thursday|Tuesday}, {March|03|Goal|Drive|Walk|April|Mar|Strut|Next month|May|Celebration} {20|Twenty|Something like 20|30|Thirty|10|21|19|More than 20|20 or so|22}, {20|Twenty|Something like 20|30|Thirty|10|21|19|More than 20|20 or so|22} #file_links\keywords4.txt,1,S] {13|Thirteen|Tough luck|12|14|15|10}, {that they were|that they are|them to be|they were} {unable to|not able to|struggling to|can not|struggle to|cannot|incapable of|helpless to|struggles to|could not|canrrrt} {reach|achieve|attain|get to|accomplish|arrive at|access|obtain|get through to|contact|grasp} {a contract|an agreement|a legal contract|a binding agreement|binding agreement|legal contract|a partnership|an understanding|a|a deal} {agreement|contract|arrangement|deal|understanding|settlement|commitment|binding agreement|legal contract|transaction|decision} {with|along with|together with|using|having|by using|utilizing|through|with the help of|by means of|by way of} Urlacher, {who is|who’s|that is|that’s|who’s going to be|who will be|who may be|who might be|who seems to be|who is responsible for|the person} {an|a good|a great|the|a|a strong|some sort of|a powerful|a particular|any|an excellent} unre #file_links\keywords5.txt,1,S] stricted {free|totally free|free of charge|no cost|cost-free|absolutely free|zero cost|100 % free|complimentary|free of cost|no charge} {agent|broker|realtor|adviser|representative|real estate agent|professional|advisor|solution|dealer|factor} {for the first time|the very first time|the first time|initially|in my ballet shoes|somebody in charge of|at last|now|responsible for|as a beginner|there’s finally someone} {in his|in the|as part of his|in their|within his|in her|within the|in|on his|during his|with his} {career|profession|job|occupation|vocation|employment|work|professional|livelihood|position|line of work}. ({AP|Elp} Photo/Phelan {M|Michael|Meters|Mirielle|L|T|D|N|E|S|R}. Ebenhack, {File|Document|Record|Report|Data file|Submit|Computer file|Data|Register|Archive|Database})